LeagueNews.co | Jess Malloy
"Luai is a great player, don't get me wrong, but sometimes a change in personnel can make all the difference in a high-pressure game like a grand final," Cronk added.
The former NRL star's comments have sparked debate among fans and experts alike, with some questioning whether Luai's injury was actually a blessing in disguise for the Panthers.
Regardless of the circumstances, one thing is for certain - Nathan Cleary's leadership and composure under pressure were crucial in guiding Penrith to victory.
The young halfback has solidified his place as one of the premier playmakers in the game, with his performance in the grand final further cementing his legacy.
As the celebrations continue in Penrith following their historic grand final win, the Panthers will no doubt be grateful for the contributions of all their players - injured or not.
And while Cooper Cronk's claim may be seen as controversial, there is no denying the impact that Jack Cogger had on turning the tide in favor of the Panthers on that fateful night in 2023.