LeagueNews.co | Cooper McEnroe
Wests Tigers fans are voicing their concerns over Benji Marshall's decision to leave young talent Tallyn Da Silva as an unused substitute during a recent match against the Raiders.
This choice has come under scrutiny, especially after reports indicated that Da Silva has been granted permission to negotiate with other clubs.
Da Silva, a promising 20-year-old, has been effectively sidelined behind veteran hooker Api Koroisau, having played 23 first-grade games since his debut in 2023.
With Koroisau's role firmly established, Da Silva has spent the majority of 2025 in reserve grade.
Though contracted until the end of 2026, Da Silva's future may be uncertain, as the Tigers have indicated he is free to leave if Koroisau's contract-also set to expire in 2026-is extended.
During the match, despite trailing 16-0 at halftime, the Tigers attempted a late comeback.
However, as the game drew to a close, Da Silva remained on the bench while Koroisau continued to play.
This decision raised eyebrows among fans, who felt the youthful energy that Da Silva could bring was sorely needed.
When questioned about why he did not utilize Da Silva, Marshall defended his choice, stating, "We needed to cover for (starting hooker) Api (Koroisau) as well, if he needed a spell, but the game's in the balance, you want your best players on the field." This comment reflects Marshall's focus on experience over youth in crucial moments.
Overall, this incident highlights the ongoing tensions within the Wests Tigers, particularly regarding the development and utilization of their younger players as they look to find a balance between immediate competitiveness and future growth.