LeagueNews.co | Jess Malloy
NRL fans are divided over the commentary style of Brad Fittler and Cameron Smith during a recent game between the Raiders and the Sharks.
Fittler's exuberant shouting over lead caller Mat Thompson when Sebastian Kris scored a late try for the Raiders led to criticism, with Fittler's repeated exclamations of "One good play! One good play!" overshadowing the moment.
In contrast, Smith offered a more understated commentary, laughing into the microphone before Kris' try without adding much verbal commentary.
This caused Thompson to be largely drowned out by his colleagues during the crucial moment of the game.
On the other hand, Fox League commentator Warren Smith received praise for his handling of the call, with no distractions from other commentators.
Smith's approach was more subdued, allowing the excitement of the moment to speak for itself.
This style is reminiscent of commentary legends like Richie Benaud, who believed in letting the action on the field and the crowd noise take precedence over excessive talking.
Smith's more restrained approach was appreciated by fans who felt that it enhanced the viewer experience and captured the atmosphere of the game.
The contrasting styles of Fittler and Smith have sparked a debate among NRL fans about the role of commentators in big moments during games.
While some enjoy the energy and enthusiasm of commentators like Fittler, others prefer a more measured and understated approach, as demonstrated by Smith.
Ultimately, the debate highlights the different preferences among viewers for how significant moments in sporting events should be called, with some valuing excitement and energy, while others prioritize allowing the moment itself to be the focus.