Kalyn Ponga claimed the 2026 Golden Boot despite playing only two matches at the Rugby League World Cup, prompting calls to change how the award is decided.
The New Zealand fullback was named the world's best international player on Thursday, ahead of teammate Casey McLean and Australian Reece Walsh.
Because the award considers Test matches only, the decision was made before Sunday's final between Australia and New Zealand.
Ponga broke his forearm in the tournament opener against Australia, then returned 23 days later and starred in the semi-final win over Tonga.
Walsh has scored five tries and made five try-assists, five line-breaks and 16 tackle breaks across three games.
McLean's four games have brought eight tries, one try-assist, 10 line-breaks and 26 tackle breaks; Ponga recorded two tries, three try-assists, three line-breaks and six tackle breaks.
Daily Telegraph columnist 'The Oracle' wrote: "WHAT AN ABSOLUTE FARCE! Reece Walsh was absolutely robbed. His stats were off the chart."
Former NRL coach Shane Flanagan told Triple M: "I think it's crazy. If we're going to pick a player before this match, it could leave you with egg on your face."
Critics want the winner announced after the final, while others favour restoring the pre-2018 system, which considered club and representative performances, including Super League and State of Origin.
Former NRL player Jarrod Croker told SEN: "I always thought the Golden Boot was just the best player in the world from Super League, NRL, State of Origin. I think that's what it should be."
Journalist John Davidson questioned whether Ponga should win after two Tests and urged a return to including club form, noting his Newcastle performances were also outstanding.