LeagueNews.co | Jason Patrick
Nathan Cleary, the star halfback of the Penrith Panthers, is facing scrutiny from NRL fans following a disappointing performance against the Parramatta Eels.
The absence of Dylan Edwards and Jarome Luai seemed to expose a "horrible" truth about the Panthers' capabilities.
Coach Ivan Cleary made the decision to rest fullback Edwards just two weeks before the NRL finals, which left the team struggling to find their rhythm.
The Panthers, who had previously won back-to-back premierships, looked like a completely different team on the field.
Cleary himself had a difficult time making an impact as the Eels took control of the game.
Clint Gutherson, in particular, displayed a masterful performance for the Eels, leading them to score four tries in the first half.
This unexpected turn of events left the reigning premiers in a state of shock.
The Panthers had not conceded more than two tries in a first half all season, making this loss particularly concerning.
The 32-18 scoreline was Penrith's most significant defeat since the previous season.
The absence of Edwards' organizational skills at the back was sorely felt by the Panthers, while the Eels took advantage of their weakened right edge, which was missing Stephen Crichton, who had filled in for Edwards.
To make matters worse, Luai suffered a dislocated shoulder, putting his availability for the entire finals series in doubt.
In the aftermath of this shocking loss, fans are questioning the true value of the players at Penrith.
While Cleary is often regarded as the team's key player, many are pointing out how much the Panthers struggled without Edwards.
The loss also opens up the possibility for the Brisbane Broncos to potentially secure the minor premiership.