LeagueNews.co | Jason Patrick
Panthers icon Greg Alexander has responded to the backlash directed at coach Ivan Cleary regarding the decision to rest "around $7.5 million worth of talent" ahead of the match against the Bulldogs. Cleary caused a stir on Tuesday by opting to rest 16 players for what was anticipated to be a thrilling encounter on Thursday night.
Nathan Cleary first announced his absence from the crucial top eight clash, which was soon followed by news that fifteen more key players would not participate. This was confirmed when Brad Schneider was the only player from the regular 17 ready to face a nearly full-strength Bulldogs team.
The Panthers' decision was informed by various factors, with Cleary acknowledging that the team was unlikely to make the top four, given the Bulldogs and Warriors were ahead on the ladder. Additionally, playing at CommBank Stadium, the home ground of the Parramatta Eels, may have further diluted any perceived home advantage as they geared up for the finals.
Club legend Alexander believes that Cleary's strategy is essential for positioning the team to compete effectively for the NRL premiership. Historically, winning the title from outside the top four has proven to be an arduous challenge for teams since the new finals system came into effect in 2011.
Alexander rebuffed accusations that the Panthers were letting fans down by not fielding their strongest team, which included an estimated $7.5 million worth of talent. He emphasized that the ultimate goal is to secure a premiership, something he achieved four consecutive times. Given that the Panthers have struggled over the past 12 weeks, including two back-to-back losses in golden point, Alexander said Cleary's difficult decision was justified.
"Isn't it about winning? Within the rules...the reason for the decision is about giving Penrith the best chance of winning the premiership. No team has ever won the competition outside of the top," Alexander stated on SEN Radio.
"Resting players now maximises that possibility of winning those four matches. After being last on the ladder after 12 rounds, they have essentially played do or die matches for 12 weeks straight."