LeagueNews.co | Jason Patrick
Nathan Cleary's impressive achievements in the NRL cannot be ignored, but there is a significant flaw in the argument that he is one of the greatest halfbacks of all time.
Despite the recent hype surrounding his performance against a weakened Warriors team, it is premature to compare him to the likes of Andrew Johns, Allan Langer, and Peter Sterling.
Phil Rothfield's claim that Cleary is on par with these legendary players has sparked a heated debate.
Cleary is undeniably a dedicated and talented player who embodies the best qualities of the game.
He is a role model for the youth and has shattered the stereotype that young players are not up to par.
At just 25 years old, he has already achieved remarkable success, including two premierships, three State of Origin victories, a World Cup win, and even a controversial Covid breach.
While Cleary's accomplishments at such a young age may be impressive, they pale in comparison to the achievements of Johns, Langer, and Sterling.
Johns had already won two Dally M awards and a premiership by the same age.
Langer boasted four Origin series wins, while Sterling had three premierships and famously bow legs.
In the end, the argument that Cleary is among the greatest halfbacks ever is based on superficial statistics.
True greatness cannot be measured solely by trophies and awards.
While Cleary may eventually earn his place among the game's legends, it is too early to crown him as such.