LeagueNews.co | Jason Patrick
Panthers fans are expressing concern about the long-term strategy for the NRL club's back-line after coach Ivan Cleary had to drop Paul Alamoti from the squad ahead of their match against the Wests Tigers.
Cleary has reinstated his son Nathan, returning from a "one-week rest," along with co-captain Isaah Yeo.
Izack Tago is also back in the lineup after serving a "one-game suspension," pushing Alamoti down to the 18th-man spot.
Since moving from the Bulldogs to the Panthers last year, Alamoti has made a significant impact under Cleary's guidance.
A Test player for Tonga, he scored a crucial try in the 2024 grand final, leading the Panthers to a victory over the Storm for their fourth consecutive premiership.
However, his status in the first-grade team has fluctuated in 2025 due to the strong performances of his teammates.
During Rounds 13 to 18, Alamoti played only one match in the top grade, as Cleary favored a lineup that included Tago, Brian To'o, Casey McLean, and Thomas Jenkins.
Despite a brilliant performance in recent matches against Parramatta and Souths upon his recall in Round 19, Alamoti finds himself sidelined again due to Tago's return and To'o's health.
With McLean and Jenkins solidifying their positions on the left side and Jenkins enjoying his best season yet, questions have arisen about Alamoti's future in the squad.
Many supporters argue that he deserves to be a part of the Panthers' best 17 and should not remain out of first-grade contention.
As the season progresses, fans are left to ponder what moves Cleary will make next in regards to Alamoti's role within the team.